I'm going to have to say Super Paper Mario. Paper Mario from the N64 is boring somewhat and I beat the game so many times and saw the ending so many times I can't count. Never played Thousand Year Door. Plus, Super Paper Mario is my favorite by far and with the original a runner-up

Post comments of your favorite.

While I have yet to play SPM, Paper Mario and the Thousand Year Door is definitely my favorite.

Paper Mario tyd

Like Yoshi, I've not yet played Super Paper Mario, however The Thousand Year Door was one of the best game's I've ever played, and easily the best family-friendly one ever.

I own and have played all three. TTYD I got to the boss and stopped b/c it was too hard. I haven't finished the first. SPM I beat a while ago.

I haven't played the original Paper Mario, but Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door is one of my favorite GameCube games. I'll go with PMTTYD.

Aw... Nobody's said Super Paper Mario yet.

I feel as though I magically appear when I am needed the most to fufill people's wishes.

Super Paper Mario is a wonderful mix of 2-D/psuedo3-D platforming and RPG's. Although, some of the characters do have a way of freaking me out... That nerdy chameleon for one. Its obsession with butterflies is borderline schitzophrenic.

My chosen favorite is Paper Mario:The Thousand Year Door
This game is filled with awe inspiring paper graphics,a deep storyline, a plethora of interesting characters. I share so many fond memories with this game. I have played and conquered all three and they are all deserving of recognition.

WELL I GUESS I'M THE ONLY ONE WHO LIKES THE ORIGINAL, THEN.

The first one was really great I think, one of the better games of the N64 era.

I prefer Thousand Year door.

I just love the ending of super paper mario, so that one for sure
I have played the second and third paper mario.
the ending of paper maroi and the thousand year door was cheesy

Thousand year door is great.

I've yet to play Super Paper Mario, but I own Paper Mario and TYD.
I'd have to say TYD is superior...and freaking awesome. :3

I've only played the original so I'll have to say that's my favorite.

I voted for the original because it's original.
But all three have great storylines. And they are also quite fun.

The original was great, but Super PM was kind of disappointing. Thousand-year door, however was epic. Huge plot, great character development, lots of side quests, actual Mario characters, and the appearance of the most epic boss in the history of bosses.

I've never played The Thousand Year Door, but I do agree that Super Paper Mario was a bit disappointing. I like the turn-based battles more, I guess. Paper Mario was just more entertaining to me.

I love TTYD. The orignal was super and was the reason why I purchased the sequel. It took everything n64 had and just made it better. I want to play it again so bad. I bought one of two copies from gamestop and it won't boot, so I'm taking it back and hoping the other copy will boot. I don't have a memery card as of now (a story I don't want to tell because it hurts), but I don't care if I have to leave my Wii on, I will play it.

As for Super Paper Mario, it's meh. A bit easy, and while it is true I played it on Dolphin, still the same (literally) nevertheless. I couldn't progress far (being stuck at 1-4 where you press - and 1 on the statue) Merlee's mansion was pretty cool though, nice soundtracks and (not) so nice Mimi-

I am in LOVE with Super paper mario because of the habit to go to and get the code in 5-1, then write it down, fail using it and go back to see the guy and get another code to see if it's the same.

I thought the Thousand Year Door

TTYD is amazing. It has a British Bob-omb. Nuff said.