What do you guys think is the best Mario of game all-time? I say Mario 64.

Well, we do have a topic going for our favorites in each genre: http://www.buizel.net/phpbb/viewtopic.php?f=73&t=43

But for best game overall, I would say either SM64 or SMG

I Say Super Mario Galaxy
Or Mario Kart Wii

I think SM64 was... well, I loved it as a kid, and loved re-playing it on the VC, I guess I am just sick of it.

My favorite is SMG2.

That's a toughie...

The one I'm most addicted to is Mario Kart Wii...but is it the best? Hardly.


I need to think....
NSMB was bad due to limited saving points...
SMG was somewhat to easy...
MKDD was cheap at times...
SM64 was too long...still haven't beaten it. xD
Classic Mario gets old fast

you know what? I'm going to say all of them...This is making me think to much. xD

My favorite one is Paper Mario 64. XD

I have high hopes for Super Mario Galaxy though.

My favorate game? Superstar saga. I absolutely love that game. Great difficulty, awesome music, and the most hilarious storyline of any game I have ever played XD

SMW

This is hard, so I reply in sections:
Platformer: SMS(SUNSHINE!!!!)
Sidescroller: SMB3 or Lost Levels
RPG: TTYD, RPG3
Kart: Wii
Party:8
Sports: Strikers Charged
I hav alot o favs! The series is just too much!

Hmm...
My favorite 3-d game would be Sunshine, mainly because of Yoshi. It's, like, the only thing Galaxy is lacking. (Next Favorite: Galaxy 2)
My favorite RPG would be Thousand Year Door, mostly because of Luigi's Adventures.
My favorite sidescroller... can't decide between Super Mario World or NSMB, but I'll go with SMW until NMSB Wii comes out-- again, because of Yoshi. In case you didn't notice yet, I favor Yoshi.

i've got to say SMG2, NSMB2, and super mario sunshine

Platformer: Galaxy
RPG: Partners in Time
Sidescroller: World
Kart: DS
Party: 7
Sports: Strikers Charged

Retro Mario just doesn't really cut it for me :/

Probably SM64 even though most of the other games were great aswell.

Probably NSMB Wii or SMW because of their powerups and long story lines

Either Super Mario World or Super Mario Kart Wii I like both a lot.

Super Mario World and Super Mario Sunshine are my favorites.

Super Mario Bros. 3 on NES. Damn, I love that game.

On the other end of the scale, New Super Mario Bros. Wii is pretty awesome!

Mario kart I! have so many memories with that game.

Hmm....Super Mario World, hands down. Excellent level design, challenging, and a chunk full of secrets that just amaze me. Anyone who hasn't played SMW isn't a gamer at all then.

Any Mario platformer, I guess. More specifically, NSMBW at the moment because I'm trying to get through all the levels without a single powerup exept the one you get from checkpoints. And probably MK3DS when I get that game.

MK wii series, the only mario games i'm good at.

SMG2
solid gameplay and... stuff...

Definitly Super Mario Galaxy 1 and 2!

I'd have to choose either All-Stars or SMW... eh, I'll just choose All-Stars + SMW to include both of them.

Super Mario World, it has some of the greatest music in video game history (in my opinion). It always brings back memories when I play it, I will probably always play it.

Either Super Mario Sunshine or Paper Mario: TTYD. But since my love for TTYD is overpowering, I'll say SMS.

Super Mario Sunshine and Mario Kart Wii. My first GameCube game, and then the game that revealed to me how violent I can get over losing in a family game. XD

that's easy 64

Super Mario Bros 3

Probably spent more time playing that game then any other in my life, practically learned to read from reading the game's strategy guide
Aside from that it's a 2d platforming masterpiece with enough secrets loaded through it to keep even the best of players coming back and discovering things they had never found before, some of the newer games are trying to return to their roots here but they're just barely missing the mark with it, not to say they aren't good they just haven't reached the level of platforming awesome this game had.

You all sicken me, SUPER MARIO LAND is the best! New Super Mario Bros sucks! I HATE that game, They should remake Super Mario Land instead of New Super Mario Bros! Birabuto Kingdom is more popular than the place in Stupid New Super Mario Bros! and I hate it because Luigi cries! WAAAAAAAAAAAAH! Mario and Luigi series is awesome too.

New Super Mario Bros isn't a remake, why would they remake it?

It's been pretty well demonstrated anyways that they prefer to make completely new games anyway instead of rehashing old content, better that way imo anyways (less lazy on the idea side)

Super Mario Advance 3

I just love that game.

Super Mario Advance 2

Super Mario World is an amazing game, and being able to carry it around with me is awesome. I've put so much time into that game, finding all 96 exits and around half the Yoshi Coins.

It's a tie between Super Mario Bros. 3 and Paper Mario: The thousand year Door...

Super mario bros 3 was my first ever Mario game played. I was 5 years old... and I didn't think it could get any better than that.

Super Mario Advance 4/ Super Mario Brothers 3 remake. I still have fond memories of my 8+ hour trip to another state and playing that game all the way up, and all the way back. It was really good.

Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars

I'm SO surprised this hasn't been mentioned yet! It's an excellent game and by far one of my overall favorite video games ever. It features Mario characters but has a game play like Final Fantasy, mostly because this game was created by both Nintendo and Square (Enix). It also includes one of my favorite Mario characters: Geno.

I strongly suggest that anyone who has not heard of this game to look it up. I can't stress enough how awesome this game is to me. XD

Its not a particular Mario game, but I LOVE SUPER SMASH BROS! Cant wait till it come out for 3ds, as i have sold my wii.

Super Mario World and Mario Kart Double Dash